Short answer: An ETF, or exchange-traded fund, pools money from many investors into a basket of securities, but its units are bought and sold on a stock exchange like shares. An index fund is an open-ended mutual fund that holds the same stocks as its benchmark index, in the same proportions, and is bought and sold at the end-of-day Net Asset Value (NAV), the fund’s per-unit value.
Last reviewed: 15 November 2026
At a glance
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| ETF | A pooled basket of securities whose units trade on a stock exchange, like shares |
| Index fund | An open-ended mutual fund holding the same stocks as its benchmark index, in the same proportions |
| NAV | Net Asset Value, the per-unit value at which index funds are bought and sold at end of day |
| SIP | Systematic investment plan, a way of investing a fixed amount at regular intervals |
| Expense ratio | The yearly running cost of a fund, expressed as a share of the money invested in it |
| Demat charges | Charges for holding securities in a demat account, the electronic account that stores shares |
What is an ETF?
An ETF collects money from many investors and uses it to buy a basket of securities, such as shares or bonds. Each unit represents a small share of that basket. Like a mutual fund, it gives a single investor exposure to many holdings at once.
The key difference from a mutual fund is how units change hands. An ETF’s units are listed on a stock exchange and bought and sold there, the same way you would trade a company’s shares. You need a demat account and a broker to do this.
Most ETFs are passive. They are built to replicate a market index, so their aim is to deliver index-like returns before expenses. They do not try to beat the index.
How is an index fund built?
An index fund is a type of mutual fund that holds the same stocks as its benchmark index, in the same proportions. If a stock makes up a certain share of the index, it makes up roughly the same share of the fund. The fund manager’s job is largely to keep the portfolio matched to the index.
Because it is open-ended, the fund creates and redeems units as investors put money in and take it out. Its purchase and sale prices are set once a day, at the end-of-day NAV.
When do you buy and sell each one?
The clearest practical difference is timing. An ETF’s price changes continuously through the trading day, so the price you see at 10 a.m. can differ from the price at 2 p.m. An index fund is bought and sold at the end-of-day NAV, so every order placed during the day is settled at the same single price.
Continuous pricing gives ETF buyers and sellers more control over the price they get, but it also means prices can move while you are deciding. An index fund removes that intraday movement, because the price is fixed until the day closes.
Can you invest a fixed amount every month in an ETF?
Not directly. ETFs do not natively support systematic investment plans (SIPs), which are schemes for investing a fixed amount at regular intervals. Some brokers offer auto-invest features that imitate SIPs, but these are a feature of the broker, not of the ETF.
Each purchase is also a separate trade. If you use an auto-invest feature, every instalment may attract brokerage and transaction charges, so the cost of frequent small investments can add up. Check the charges your broker applies before setting one up.
What do trading costs add up to?
ETFs usually carry a lower expense ratio than many actively managed funds, but the expense ratio is not the whole cost. Buying or selling an ETF incurs brokerage and transaction charges on each trade, along with demat charges where applicable. These can offset the lower expense ratio.
Consider a hypothetical example, with invented figures for illustration only. Suppose you invest Rs 1,00,000 (one lakh) in an ETF with an expense ratio of 0.20% a year, against an index fund at 0.30%. The ETF costs Rs 200 a year in fund expenses and the index fund Rs 300, a saving of Rs 100. If buying and selling the ETF in that year costs Rs 250 in brokerage and transaction charges, the trading costs are larger than the saving, and the ETF ends up costing Rs 150 more for the year.
The example is simplified. Actual charges vary by broker and fund, and the outcome changes with the amount invested and how often you trade.
Frequently asked questions
Is an ETF the same as a mutual fund?
No. Both pool money from many investors, but an ETF’s units are bought and sold on a stock exchange like shares, while mutual fund units are bought and sold through the fund at its NAV.
Do ETFs beat the index they track?
Most ETFs are passive and aim to deliver index-like returns before expenses. They are built to match the index, not to beat it.
Can I invest in an ETF through a SIP?
ETFs do not natively support SIPs. Some brokers offer auto-invest features that imitate them, and each instalment may attract trading charges.
Are ETF costs always lower than index fund costs?
Not necessarily. ETFs often have a lower expense ratio, but brokerage, transaction and demat charges on each trade can offset that saving.
Sources and last check
Facts in this article were checked against the sources below on 15 November 2026. Rules and figures can change; check the primary source before acting.
- 5paisa.com (broker education)
- zerodha.com (broker education)
- nism.ac.in (financial press or official education site)
- groww.in (broker education)
- upstox.com (broker education)
This article is general information, not investment advice. MyFinanceBandhu is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser.